The Bully / Aggressor
You know this person. Everyone knows this person. They are the one teachers watch. The one other students avoid or orbit carefully. They take up space. They dominate conversations. They make people uncomfortable on purpose. The school has a file on them.
What the aggression is actually about
The bully is not mean because they feel good about themselves. They are mean because at some point — usually young, usually repeatedly — someone with power over them made them feel small. A parent. An older sibling. A coach. Someone who was supposed to protect them but didn't. Or worse, someone who was supposed to protect them and was the one who hurt them.
So they learned a survival rule: never be small again. Never be the one who gets hurt. Be the one who hurts first. Dominate before you can be dominated. The aggression is not about enjoying power. It is about never being powerless again.
This is why normal youth ministry does not reach them. They do not present as needy. They do not ask for help. They do not cry in small groups. They look like they have it together — or at least like they do not need you. But underneath the performance is a kid who is terrified that if they stop being the biggest presence in the room, they will disappear entirely. Or worse, they will become what they were before.
“Power is the only thing that keeps me safe. If I stop, I become what I was before.”
What this person actually needs is not to be told to stop being mean. They need to be in the presence of someone who is strong and does not use that strength against them. Someone who refuses to be dominated but also refuses to dominate back. Someone who shows them that safety does not require being the scariest person in the room. What they do NOT need is another authority figure who treats them like a behavior problem, or another peer who is either afraid of them or trying to fix them.
The good news for someone carrying this.
Mark 5:1-20 · The man with the legion
There was a man who lived in a graveyard. Not because he wanted to. Because no one could control him. He was violent. He broke chains. He screamed at night. He cut himself with stones. The whole region knew about him. Travelers avoided that shoreline. Parents used him as a warning. He was the local terror.
What most people miss in this story is that the man was not possessed because he was evil. He was possessed because he was broken. Something had happened to him. The demons had names — Legion, because there were many. This was not a single moment of rebellion. This was accumulated trauma with nowhere to go. The violence was not power. It was desperation.
When Jesus got out of the boat, everyone else ran. But Jesus walked straight toward him. The man came at Him screaming. And Jesus did not flinch. He did not try to manage him. He did not lecture him. He did not treat him like a problem to be solved from a safe distance. He stood there. Strong. Unafraid. And He spoke directly to the thing that was destroying the man from the inside.
What Jesus did next is the hinge of the whole story. He cast out the demons. But He did not do it to prove His power. He did it to free the man. And when the townspeople came back and saw the man sitting there — clothed, calm, in his right mind — they were terrified. Not of the man. Of Jesus. Because they had never seen power used like that before. Power that did not dominate. Power that restored.
The man wanted to follow Jesus. He begged to get in the boat. But Jesus told him to go home. To go back to the people who had chained him and tell them what God had done. Not what he had done. What God had done. The man who had been the most violent person in the region became the first missionary to the Decapolis.
This is the same Jesus who walked into Jerusalem knowing He would be arrested, beaten, mocked, and executed. He had the power to stop it. He could have called down angels. He could have walked away. But He did not use His power to protect Himself. He used it to absorb the violence aimed at us. He let Himself be dominated so that we would never have to dominate again to feel safe.
“When they came to Jesus, they saw the man who had been possessed by the legion of demons, sitting there, dressed and in his right mind.”
Mark 5:15He is the only person who has ever had ultimate power and used it entirely for others.
Practical ways to love this person well.
Show up without flinching
The first thing your friend needs is to be in the presence of someone who is not afraid of them and not trying to dominate them back. Do not avoid them. Do not manage them. Just be around. Sit near them at lunch. Show up where they are. Do not perform friendship. Just be present without an agenda. Most people either fear them or try to fix them. You are doing neither.
Refuse to be dominated, but do not fight for control
Your friend will test you. They will push. They will try to make you small or make you leave. Do not let them. But also do not push back the same way. If they insult you, do not crumble. If they try to control the conversation, do not fight for it. Just stay. Be calm. Be solid. Show them that you are not afraid and you are not going anywhere. This is incarnational. You are showing them what strength looks like when it is not being used as a weapon.
Ask about the thing nobody asks about
At some point, when you have been around long enough, ask them a question that goes under the surface. Not 'why are you so angry' — that is an accusation. But something like: 'What was it like growing up in your house?' or 'Who taught you that you had to be like this?' Most people only talk to them about their behavior. You are asking about their story. You are assuming there is a reason. That alone is good news.
Do not try to fix them before you have earned the right
Your friend has been lectured their whole life. By teachers. By parents. By coaches. By everyone. Do not add to that pile. Do not tell them to stop being mean. Do not give them advice about anger management. Not yet. First, be someone who stays. Someone who is not afraid. Someone who sees them as more than their worst behavior. You will know when the door is open to say something harder. It is not open yet.
When the door opens, tell them about the man in the graveyard
When the time comes to talk about Jesus, do not start with 'you need to change.' Start with the story in Mark 5. Tell them about the man everyone avoided. The man who was violent because he was broken. The man Jesus walked toward when everyone else ran. Ask them: 'What do you think it felt like to be that guy? To be the one everyone is afraid of?' Then tell them what Jesus did. That He had the power to destroy the man but used it to free him instead. That He is still that kind of strong. Your friend has never met power like that.
Do not leave when they push you away
At some point, your friend will try to make you leave. They will say something cruel. They will test whether you are actually different or just another person who will bail when it gets hard. Do not bail. Do not match their energy. Just stay. Say something like: 'I am not going anywhere.' That sentence alone is the gospel before you ever say the word Jesus. Because the God they have never met is the one who does not leave when it gets ugly.
What not to do.
Do not try to be their therapist. You are not equipped for that and it is not your job. If they disclose abuse, tell a trusted adult immediately. You can be a friend and a witness to the gospel without carrying what you are not meant to carry. Do not mistake their aggression for confidence. It is not. It is fear. But also do not pity them. Pity is condescending and they will smell it immediately. What you are offering is respect — the kind that sees them clearly and stays anyway. After you have the gospel conversation, nothing may change immediately. They may not soften. They may not stop being aggressive. They may not start coming to church. Stay anyway. Because the gospel is not a transaction. It is an announcement of what is true whether they believe it yet or not. And your presence — your refusal to leave — is part of that announcement.
Mark 5:1-20 · Philippians 2:5-11
Mark 5 shows them a person like them — violent, isolated, terrifying — and what Jesus does when He meets them. Philippians 2 shows them what real power looks like: Jesus, who had all of it, and used it by giving it up.